Best Restaurants on St John
ZoZo’s at Caneel Bay
For a fine dining experience with unforgettable sunset views, ZoZo’s is hard to beat. Located on the Caneel Bay property, this upscale Italian-inspired restaurant features house-made pasta, creative seafood dishes, and a romantic atmosphere. Reservations are a must.
La Tapa
A long-time favorite in Cruz Bay, La Tapa combines Mediterranean flavors with Caribbean flair. Their ever-changing menu focuses on fresh, local ingredients, and the intimate waterfront setting makes it perfect for a memorable night out.
Extra Virgin Bistro
Known for its farm-to-table approach, Extra Virgin Bistro showcases herbs, greens, and vegetables grown right on their property. The dishes are elegant yet approachable, with standout seafood and hand-cut steaks.
The Speakeasy
Chef Vincent Alterio’s intimate and creative restaurant, The Speakeasy, offers an exceptional dining experience. Open only Thursday through Sunday, this hidden gem delights guests with inventive dishes that blend island flavors with global influences. Be sure to reserve early as seating is limited.
Lime Inn
If you love incredible tacos, Lime Inn is a must-visit. This vibrant spot serves up flavorful, fresh tacos that capture the spirit of the islands (along with some of the best margaritas around!). Don’t miss their sister taco boat, Lime Out, which offers the same great flavors in a unique waterside setting.
The Longboard
For a more casual vibe, head to The Longboard for bright and flavorful island-style tapas, poke bowls, and craft cocktails. The open-air setting and creative menu make it a great spot to relax after a day at the beach.
Morgan’s Mango
If you’re in the mood for Caribbean cuisine, Morgan’s Mango offers a festive atmosphere and a menu full of island favorites like conch fritters, lobster, and plantain dishes. Their extensive rum selection is worth exploring too.
Best Cafes and Breakfast Spots
High Tide Bar & Seafood Grill
Located just steps from the Cruz Bay ferry dock, High Tide is a popular waterfront spot serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily starting at 8 a.m. Plus, they offer convenient luggage storage, making it perfect for your arrival or departure meal.
Cruz Bay Landing
A go-to spot for breakfast, brunch, and coffee, Cruz Bay Landing sits conveniently near the ferry dock. From hearty omelets to fresh pastries and espresso drinks, it’s a great place to start your day.
North Shore Deli
Perfect for grabbing a quick coffee, smoothie, or sandwich before heading to the beach. They also offer picnic-ready lunch options if you’re planning a day in the park.
Colombo’s Smoothie Stand
On the North Shore road, this colorful stand is a must-visit for refreshing smoothies and light bites with a view.
Coco Jim’s
For a true local roadside experience, stop by Coco Jim’s for their famous chicken leg and a refreshing Painkiller cocktail. This laid-back spot is perfect for grabbing a delicious, no-frills meal and a tropical drink to go. It’s a must-visit for anyone wanting a taste of authentic island flavor on the go.
Best Bars and Nightlife
Beach Bar
No visit to St John is complete without a stop at the iconic Beach Bar on Cruz Bay Beach. Cold drinks, live music, and a laid-back vibe make it a favorite for locals and visitors alike.
Drink
If you’re looking for craft cocktails with a view, Drink offers a creative menu of mixed drinks and a lively happy hour scene right by the water.
Windmill Bar
Perched high above Cruz Bay, Windmill Bar offers panoramic views, live music, and some of the best sunsets on the island - all with a drink in hand.
Tips for Foodies Visiting St John
✅ Make dinner reservations in advance, especially during high season
✅ Many places add a service charge, so check your bill before tipping
✅ Try the local catch of the day! Fresh fish is a highlight here
✅ Reef-safe sunscreen and casual resort wear are perfect for almost every venue
At Cruz Bay Realty, we know that experiencing the food and culture of St John is part of what makes island life so special. Whether you’re here for a visit or thinking about making St John your home, we’re happy to share our favorite spots and insider tips to help you feel like a local.
