Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

Browse Homes
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
SEE ALL PHOTOS
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
445 Chocolate Hole, St John
Courtesy of Cruz Bay Realty
Sold

445 Chocolate Hole, St John

445 Chocolate Hole, St John, St. John, VI 00830

$2,000,000
La Papaya is a versatile 2-unit concrete villa in Chocolate Hole, offering sweeping sunset views. This solidly built property boasts a two unit layout, allowing for added benefits for buyers exploring loan options. The main house features 3 spacious bedrooms, designed with light & airy beach-inspired decor. Open concept living, dining, & kitchen areas flow seamlessly out to an expansive deck. The lower level apartment offers 2 additional bedrooms, separate living area, & private access, ideal for guests or rental income. Between the two units lies a brick-paved pool deck with a large pool & jacuzzi with a waterfall feature. Professionally landscaped with tropical blooms, fruit trees, & a grassy lawn, La Papaya is a private, welcoming retreat with excellent rental potential + room to grow.

5
beds

4
baths

4,126 Sq.Ft. LIVING AREA

0.6 Acres lot

Features & Amenities

Interior

  • total bedrooms5
  • Total bathrooms4
  • full bathrooms4

Area & Lot

  • Status Sold
  • Date Sold June 25, 2026
  • Living Area4,126 Sq.Ft.
  • Total Area4,126 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Area0.6 Acres
  • MLS® ID25-160
  • TypeResidential
  • YEAR BUILT1998
  • NeighborhoodSouth Shore
  • View DescriptionPanoramic

Exterior

  • PoolYes
  • roofTile
  • lot featuresGrade

Financial

  • Sales Price$2,000,000
  • HOA $460
  • Zoning R-2Residential
Amanda Arquit

Amanda Arquit

South Shore

Explore

Work With Us

We bring together a mix of integrity, imagination and an inexhaustible work ethic, striving to make each buying and selling experience the best possible.

Follow Us on Instagram